Shameless Goods logo – funny buttons and magnets
Green pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
White pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
White magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Pink pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Pink magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Grey pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Grey magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Green pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Green magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Blue pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Blue magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Infographic for 2.25" pinback buttons and magnets with text and website URL.
Green pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
White pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
White magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Pink pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Pink magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Grey pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Grey magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Green pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Green magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Blue pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Blue magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Infographic for 2.25" pinback buttons and magnets with text and website URL.
Green pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
White pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
White magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Pink pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Pink magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Grey pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Grey magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Green pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Green magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Blue pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Blue magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Infographic for 2.25" pinback buttons and magnets with text and website URL.
Green pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
White pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
White magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Pink pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Pink magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Grey pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Grey magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Green pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Green magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Blue pinback button with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Blue magnet with the text 'It only seems kinky the first time' and an image of handcuffs.
Infographic for 2.25" pinback buttons and magnets with text and website URL.

“It Only Seems Kinky the First Time” Button or Magnet

$4.00

Kink? It’s all about perspective. This pinback button or magnet features the iconic phrase “It only seems kinky the first time” alongside a bold illustration of handcuffs. Whether you’re a seasoned deviant or just here for the innuendo, this little accessory is perfect for sex-positive rebels, dungeon decor, or fridge-based flirtation. Stick it somewhere visible. Let the judgment begin. Pairs well with flirtatious banter, restraint jokes, and kink‑positive pride.

Category: ,
Tags: , ,

More Goodies in This Collection

Consent is sexy. Explore the rest of the Yes, No, Red collection

Additional information

Weight .5 oz
Dimensions 1.25 × 1.25 × .5 in
Color

Grey, Blue, White, Green, Pink
Style

Pinback button, Magnet

Reviews

There are no reviews yet.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

You may also like…

Shameless Goods is a mother–daughter duo

crafting spicy, snarky handmade goods since 2015.

We also run Witticisms R Us, where we slap our sarcasm

onto tees, hoodies, mugs, and anything else that’ll hold still.
Yep, we’re on Etsy too.